{"version":"upa:cross-source-shape-evaluation:v1","sourceSha256":"e083b217283bfb559996d24a32e7826935cb9ff84c30b28a5af0b820f66b81bb","corpusSha256":"a1e51d00eba03aa1ee26faef31e3d62d4743171ace3cc43a5f1d05e0e38d750f","review":"Assistant-reviewed fixed examples selected after inspecting registry masks and initial algorithm output, not independent expert labels; labels concern geometry, not cultural or family identity.","cases":[{"id":"case-1","seed":{"patternId":"p34_-_b00","geometrySha256":"96060321b776e239e4307b579d8803afc77e18503233c4231d9228b105eca022","occurrenceId":"i1-e1bd0548527fcd097f99604deccc668b3cf3887ffcbd3174022274277ad83919"},"target":{"patternId":"p38_-_b00","geometrySha256":"08827eb63c4860289beeed4bef870d6bd21931610d04f0fb2961067da25a795a","occurrenceId":"i1-f2f91c003084be10ab89970367b2fdbbd54ef28f46041bba6b35ed6e2300540f"},"label":"same-shape","reason":"Both masks are fully filled 3 × 3 squares; colours are not identity.","observation":"exact-visible-shape","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":{"found":true,"pairId":"link2-77400b04e806f1b83439963587fe2dc6887ff534eea36826a43b4e0a2ebbdd52","scope":"source/object group; occurrences may differ from the fixed pair"},"evidence":{"totalInk":9,"knownInk":9,"geometryMatches":9,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":0}},{"id":"case-2","seed":{"patternId":"p34_-_b00","geometrySha256":"96060321b776e239e4307b579d8803afc77e18503233c4231d9228b105eca022","occurrenceId":"i1-e1bd0548527fcd097f99604deccc668b3cf3887ffcbd3174022274277ad83919"},"target":{"patternId":"p40_-_b00","geometrySha256":"e8c2ffacc151eb214e504a8a0d4b4fe04e26eda09f3b4f64acf958d9167d1806","occurrenceId":"i1-266ba7ce5fe88c01fda6c11431b31ddda2a79e0e4e75ecbc564dc7a5ee3ea28b"},"label":"partial-consistent","reason":"Only one column of a 3 × 3 square is visible at the page edge; the rest cannot be judged.","observation":"partial-consistent","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":null,"evidence":{"totalInk":9,"knownInk":3,"geometryMatches":3,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":6}},{"id":"case-3","seed":{"patternId":"p34_-_b00","geometrySha256":"96060321b776e239e4307b579d8803afc77e18503233c4231d9228b105eca022","occurrenceId":"i1-8c3991c83f80dee6952217f5e13842373aebf36446216677295aec9582e71d35"},"target":{"patternId":"p38_-_b00","geometrySha256":"08827eb63c4860289beeed4bef870d6bd21931610d04f0fb2961067da25a795a","occurrenceId":"i1-e34985732dc4e17ce408f7cf462eb8b52aaa559d0c0c5317310ea3cc902a9bbe"},"label":"different-shape","reason":"The 4 × 4 masks have 14 and 16 occupied cells; a D4 transform cannot make them identical.","observation":"differences","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":null,"evidence":{"totalInk":14,"knownInk":14,"geometryMatches":14,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":2,"unknown":0,"outside":0}},{"id":"case-4","seed":{"patternId":"p25_-_b00","geometrySha256":"afe0096411400becbed799e589ea00917e24d389146b40a7d83d16d0ca0431ed","occurrenceId":"i1-8e3eaff8a0d55ecf0d1e8ae55d7e4b58c336c9ffe1eb0237c04c2f5097a2b08e"},"target":{"patternId":"p34_-_b00","geometrySha256":"96060321b776e239e4307b579d8803afc77e18503233c4231d9228b105eca022","occurrenceId":"i1-e1bd0548527fcd097f99604deccc668b3cf3887ffcbd3174022274277ad83919"},"label":"different-shape","reason":"The 3 × 3 masks contain five diagonal-cross cells versus nine cells.","observation":"no-proposal","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"case-5","seed":{"patternId":"p25_-_b00","geometrySha256":"afe0096411400becbed799e589ea00917e24d389146b40a7d83d16d0ca0431ed","occurrenceId":"i1-8e3eaff8a0d55ecf0d1e8ae55d7e4b58c336c9ffe1eb0237c04c2f5097a2b08e"},"target":{"patternId":"p40_-_b00","geometrySha256":"e8c2ffacc151eb214e504a8a0d4b4fe04e26eda09f3b4f64acf958d9167d1806","occurrenceId":"i1-5c269bba7a6ad056ef3fd4576dea331f4ca2d3f7d392ecad936299496dc720dc"},"label":"different-shape","reason":"The 3 × 3 diagonal cross has five cells; the other mask has nine.","observation":"no-proposal","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"case-6","seed":{"patternId":"p34_-_b00","geometrySha256":"96060321b776e239e4307b579d8803afc77e18503233c4231d9228b105eca022","occurrenceId":"i1-e1bd0548527fcd097f99604deccc668b3cf3887ffcbd3174022274277ad83919"},"target":{"patternId":"p41_-_b00","geometrySha256":"91caa42ae0a6a92520317fc363e0899b009e9912704a71a4ec3c126e3f6dee6f","occurrenceId":"i1-b7bc90700e23a64dbdb34c1e14f5a083a972dafae1aa41d99324b15cb5891e22"},"label":"different-shape","reason":"A 3 × 3 filled square and a 5 × 5 cross have different dimensions and cell counts.","observation":"no-proposal","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"case-7","seed":{"patternId":"p41_-_b00","geometrySha256":"91caa42ae0a6a92520317fc363e0899b009e9912704a71a4ec3c126e3f6dee6f","occurrenceId":"i1-53cbdf7c9183f9f72e8aa4a5f2dd34ea5e10a5158847ca9b6db040a468874a50"},"target":{"patternId":"p38_-_b00","geometrySha256":"08827eb63c4860289beeed4bef870d6bd21931610d04f0fb2961067da25a795a","occurrenceId":"i1-e34985732dc4e17ce408f7cf462eb8b52aaa559d0c0c5317310ea3cc902a9bbe"},"label":"different-shape","reason":"The 4 × 4 masks contain nine and sixteen cells.","observation":"no-proposal","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"case-8","seed":{"patternId":"p12_-_b00","geometrySha256":"3d54c0ebf4f167392b0e6b52132a7288b97245687d828187841f9c905c4b7e40","occurrenceId":"i1-cdc328cafed7b8d3e2375914e265552966a313693bd9e848a574b0ba107a8c69"},"target":{"patternId":"p25_-_b00","geometrySha256":"afe0096411400becbed799e589ea00917e24d389146b40a7d83d16d0ca0431ed","occurrenceId":"i1-fbe1186005bab17b11c9f0af9490364dcc17b774ba46bad990d84b9ef73717b0"},"label":"different-shape","reason":"Both have nine cells, but the diagonal band and branching figure do not coincide under D4.","observation":"no-proposal","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":null,"retrieval":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"case-9","seed":{"patternId":"p08_L_b04","geometrySha256":"972ea9ad917f338b259393b564c7e33f1ff29ce467b40c2cc358a7f6ba143978","occurrenceId":"i1-2e74be75b0476c11dbc11f25d2c16b03983f5439ecea51c7eae57ce302e67d0e"},"target":{"patternId":"p09_-_b06","geometrySha256":"956825187fcfba133eaed895d1413283af1484dfd237f759dbd246855076b940","occurrenceId":"i1-5fbd80c13e8d1b58d6d45c4f34ab78b343365acf3513ed116c5513b485151ad2"},"label":"same-shape","reason":"Five-cell open frame rotated and recoloured; positions differ.","witness":{"seedRows":["##","#.","##"],"targetRows":["#.#","###"],"transform":"r270","palette":{"D":"A"}},"observation":"exact-visible-shape","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":{"masksMatch":true,"transformationMatches":true,"paletteMatches":true},"retrieval":{"found":true,"pairId":"link2-874c323e661b2a3b1d4be9aba42fee12d58c2b15700b7e48d5cbbdbaa7d12d8c","scope":"source/object group; occurrences may differ from the fixed pair"},"evidence":{"totalInk":5,"knownInk":5,"geometryMatches":5,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":0}},{"id":"case-10","seed":{"patternId":"p08_R_b03","geometrySha256":"b153a05b8758df4016915aba53e183407418b42569c759c71d18455ac02d22f5","occurrenceId":"i1-cc906ddbd097f82502e20fc4b7165396d7aca4d314ae670ec7f6c0b254a3a07f"},"target":{"patternId":"p13_-_b05","geometrySha256":"0ab6116b8b7b3cdc9fd7d9d70b3bcc8c3b9de58e7c2738b3657d8d89f41b2bf8","occurrenceId":"i1-3c6a117de216f683f86f43ed6e77363e40917e5f9d2113a901b101f0dd42b1a5"},"label":"same-shape","reason":"Eight-cell comb rotated by 180 degrees.","witness":{"seedRows":["#####","#.#.#"],"targetRows":["#.#.#","#####"],"transform":"r180","palette":{"A":"A"}},"observation":"exact-visible-shape","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":{"masksMatch":true,"transformationMatches":true,"paletteMatches":true},"retrieval":{"found":true,"pairId":"link2-9aca6c492a3fc649b0b7363d114ae978e73eb38c7941f3731764fba93addc7fc","scope":"source/object group; occurrences may differ from the fixed pair"},"evidence":{"totalInk":8,"knownInk":8,"geometryMatches":8,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":0}},{"id":"case-11","seed":{"patternId":"p08_R_b08","geometrySha256":"90f2312b140e2de979d4fbcc1c2c4c278441eca996133ecd38a39e9354101e00","occurrenceId":"i1-d3bdede02304b824957803b9b1adafc1c99dea1d6379c6dea5d3fc5cfabc6ecd"},"target":{"patternId":"p25_-_b01","geometrySha256":"c8c69b7499246b6e86cfa452aedea656521ddf0c472203725b39a8425522e472","occurrenceId":"i1-bed121cd85007cb16b2845f132a7dd027726d38f428f66ec24593dca87362f89"},"label":"same-shape","reason":"A multicolour repeat unit reflected vertically; semantic identity is unconfirmed.","witness":{"seedRows":["#..#.",".##..","####.","####.",".##..","#####"],"targetRows":["#####",".##..","####.","####.",".##..","#..#."],"transform":"m180","palette":{"A":"A","D":"D"}},"observation":"exact-visible-shape","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":{"masksMatch":true,"transformationMatches":true,"paletteMatches":true},"retrieval":{"found":true,"pairId":"link2-6a0e4abd8490a787eca24d945ee9becef3fbd6fac5a945ff1ef594f50551ea4f","scope":"source/object group; occurrences may differ from the fixed pair"},"evidence":{"totalInk":19,"knownInk":19,"geometryMatches":19,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":0}},{"id":"case-12","seed":{"patternId":"p09_-_b03","geometrySha256":"ecac4f3dd49c6595be86d176abc5e588a16c50c0654995534254b742e3e9042d","occurrenceId":"i1-dffdc16e29847b22b9db4ffd8fe201a301bc3b393402757e5202230ab061c28b"},"target":{"patternId":"p19_-_b00","geometrySha256":"d8cac0066a899ac026a796d7bf3d3b672d8cacc21a81015d94c64f1de0f44da8","occurrenceId":"i1-ba7a8e115a1e5f469fc31ba7bcc0de895a3bcc710ad624865091bf0f6f8a1df0"},"label":"same-shape","reason":"Five-cell asymmetric mask reflected vertically.","witness":{"seedRows":["..#.",".#.#","#..#"],"targetRows":["#..#",".#.#","..#."],"transform":"m180","palette":{"A":"A"}},"observation":"exact-visible-shape","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":{"masksMatch":true,"transformationMatches":true,"paletteMatches":true},"retrieval":{"found":true,"pairId":"link2-b87c0ff8fa6833c2a04780e2852e5dad4743cc698daace8a55792e7765b16f64","scope":"source/object group; occurrences may differ from the fixed pair"},"evidence":{"totalInk":5,"knownInk":5,"geometryMatches":5,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":0}},{"id":"case-13","seed":{"patternId":"p08_R_b09","geometrySha256":"4ff22229fc7e35b24a8639ef8c8355a913a89761e484899f4a07f2f20ecc20bb","occurrenceId":"i1-1cea608ac6fb4eb67d5de85c8c16fd327373151912d6486fd2c9b5fce721918d"},"target":{"patternId":"p25_-_b00","geometrySha256":"afe0096411400becbed799e589ea00917e24d389146b40a7d83d16d0ca0431ed","occurrenceId":"i1-8e3eaff8a0d55ecf0d1e8ae55d7e4b58c336c9ffe1eb0237c04c2f5097a2b08e"},"label":"same-shape","reason":"Five-cell diagonal crosses use different colours and coordinates.","witness":{"seedRows":["#.#",".#.","#.#"],"targetRows":["#.#",".#.","#.#"],"transform":"r0","palette":{"D":"C"}},"observation":"exact-visible-shape","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":{"masksMatch":true,"transformationMatches":true,"paletteMatches":true},"retrieval":{"found":true,"pairId":"link2-141d2f104faa19b8a3c4f3965a0d43e011cc93a3e1d13eb720f2002c20798285","scope":"source/object group; occurrences may differ from the fixed pair"},"evidence":{"totalInk":5,"knownInk":5,"geometryMatches":5,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":0}},{"id":"case-14","seed":{"patternId":"p13_-_b01","geometrySha256":"ff8d51214d510eda0c03588145fcb25c2fabf7ca15906bccbf9222e1971e32ac","occurrenceId":"i1-3a26d1f129384926a2ac016a4406394aa46f99d4bbbc00f467ffeba27174824c"},"target":{"patternId":"p24_-_b00","geometrySha256":"55a3a9cf2b305340b98d82c868823adaff3a5ac36721d60084ae264b8d15d774","occurrenceId":"i1-b065aa9cc9e5740d3e8aaa6b6079f97e683d9c7de46ea3b0fef06963bd5f31da"},"label":"same-shape","reason":"Eight-cell shape changes orientation, aspect ratio, colour and position.","witness":{"seedRows":[".##.","####",".##."],"targetRows":[".#.","###","###",".#."],"transform":"r90","palette":{"F":"D"}},"observation":"exact-visible-shape","agrees":true,"witnessCheck":{"masksMatch":true,"transformationMatches":true,"paletteMatches":true},"retrieval":{"found":true,"pairId":"link2-abe1910b9479e55c3a8f3d0db9bbe00e95e5925cc52f24bfc205faa5c920b519","scope":"source/object group; occurrences may differ from the fixed pair"},"evidence":{"totalInk":8,"knownInk":8,"geometryMatches":8,"geometryDifferences":0,"missing":0,"extra":0,"unknown":0,"outside":0}}],"method":"direct-pair-evidence and bounded positive group retrieval","scope":"shape-only; no independent expert review; no corpus-wide precision or recall","groups":[{"label":"same-shape","agrees":7,"total":7},{"label":"partial-consistent","agrees":1,"total":1},{"label":"different-shape","agrees":6,"total":6}],"positiveRetrieval":{"found":7,"total":7,"scope":"selected positive source/object groups only; not corpus-wide recall"}}